Europe’s low-carbon transition makes economic sense
At the very outset of its mandate, the new European Commission presented the European Green Deal, establishing the objective of becoming the first climate-neutral bloc in the world by 2050. The initiative emphasises the seriousness which the European Commission places on the climate and biodiversity challenges Europe faces in the coming decades and proposes an unprecedented mobilisation of resources to finance a transition to a sustainable economy.
Last year, the Future of Manufacturing in Europe (FOME) project – an EU initiative proposed by the European Parliament and delegated to Eurofound by the European Commission – published findings projecting that a successful transition towards a low-carbon economy, as defined by the Paris Climate Agreement, would result in a 1.1% growth in GDP and a 0.5% growth in employment in the EU by 2030. This was compared to a ‘business as usual’ baseline forecast. On a national level, the study projected that Latvia, Malta and Belgium would experience the largest boost to GDP. At close to 6%, the projected growth in Latvia’s GDP was by far the most significant – this being largely attributed to the energy efficiency investment required and the reduction in fossil fuel imports relative to GDP.
According to the research, Belgium was also among the countries that would experience a marked increase in employment from the economic restructuring required to fully implement the Paris Agreement, resulting in increased consumer expenditure in labour-intensive sectors such as retail, hospitality and catering. Spain and Germany were projected to experience a similar phenomenon. In the case of Spain, the report pinpoints the importance of solar photovoltaic electricity and lower consumer energy prices in generating disposable income to the benefit of labour-intensive sectors. The only country projected to experience a (comparatively marginal) net decrease in employment was Poland, due to its large coal-mining sector.
The projections detailed in the report were modelled on a basis that there would be no significant labour market frictions from the transition, in particular that the labour force would adapt to the structural change with regards to skill requirements. To this extent, the findings show how effective and comprehensive cooperation between regional, national and European levels - as well as between governments and social partners - in the transition can bring tangible economic and employment dividends. What is also evident in the research is that there are few sectors that would be broadly negatively impacted by this transition; of the nine sectors analysed, just two - utilities and mining - would see a net job loss compared to the baseline scenario. Even agriculture, often considered to be adversely exposed to job loss from a low-carbon transition, would see a 0.5% job growth compared to the baseline scenario by 2030.
Despite these findings, it would be remiss to downplay or negate apprehension over the challenges of making a low-carbon transition to be found in many rural areas and communities throughout Europe. The European Commission has emphasised the role of Member States in identifying regional priorities and committing to match each euro from the Just Transition Fund with money from the European Regional Development Fund. President von der Leyen, in particular, has emphasised the need to prioritise vulnerable regions and communities and ensure that no-one is left behind.
There are clear reasons for this sensitivity to regional balance. Eurofound’s 2019 European Jobs Monitor shows that employment growth in capital city regions in the EU’s largest Member States outstripped that of other domestic regions between 2002 and 2017. The European Quality of Life Survey 2016 also showed that people in rural areas report a lower quality of life and life satisfaction, as well as more difficulty in making ends meet , than those living in Europe’s capitals and metropolitan centres. It is therefore important that the Green Deal is rolled out and communicated in a way that demonstrates how it can mitigate, not accentuate, regional imbalances.
Europe’s economy, and particularly the economy of rural Europe, may have it all to gain from a low-carbon transition, but getting everyone on board could turn out to be the greatest challenge.
Read more:
European Commission: A European Green Deal
Eurofound: Energy scenario: Employment implications of the Paris Climate Agreement
Read further:
Publication: What makes capital cities the best places to live?
Publication: Is rural Europe being left behind?
Publication: European Jobs Monitor 2019: Shifts in the employment structure at regional level
Data and resources: Regional shifts in employment structure 2002-2017
Author
James Higgins
Communication OfficerJames Higgins is the press and media liaison person at Eurofound. He is also responsible for the Eurofound Talks podcast series.
Related content
27 January 2020
What makes capital cities the best places to live?
Quality of life data show that in most countries, the capital city has advantages compared to the regions outside the capital. In light of the continued growth of capital city populations and the concentration of resources within them, this policy brief explores the source of the advantages of capital cities in quality of life. Are these advantages mostly related to specific demographics that these cities nurture and attract? Or do these advantages stem from opportunities that major cities provide due to their scale and economic growth?
The policy brief aims to clarify why policy should focus on both the economy and society when it comes to advancing economic, social and territorial cohesion.
2 May 2019
Is rural Europe being left behind?
Rural communities have distinctive patterns of economic development and social life. Previous research has highlighted a rural–urban divide across several dimensions of quality of life. For instance, living standards are lower on average in rural areas. This policy brief aims to draw policymakers’ attention to aspects of quality of life where rural dwellers are doing less well than the urban population, focusing on three topics: financial security, connectedness and life satisfaction. The study finds that in terms of financial situation and subjective well-being, the rural regions of southern and eastern European Member States are indeed falling behind. Older rural residents of these countries, particularly, experience high levels of disadvantage.
7 October 2019
European Jobs Monitor 2019: Shifts in the employment structure at regional level
Accumulating evidence indicates that large metropolitan centres are faring much better than other regions within the Member States of the EU. Such interregional inequality contributes to disenchantment with existing political systems, which in turn can weaken the social bonds that ground democratic systems. This is the context for the 2019 edition of the European Jobs Monitor, which analyses shifts in the employment structure – meaning change in the distribution of employment across occupations and sectors – of the EU regions. The analysis covers 130 regions of 9 Member States, which together account for nearly 4 out of 5 EU workers. The study finds that, while Member States are becoming more similar in their employment structures, regions within the same country are becoming more disparate. It also finds that cities have a disproportionately high share of well-paid, high-skilled services employment alongside growth in low-paid employment. The findings support continued EU regional policy assistance of regions in danger of being left behind.
12 February 2019
Energy scenario: Employment implications of the Paris Climate Agreement
This report explores the potential employment and economic impacts of an EU transition to a low-carbon economy by 2030 – on the EU, and on other regions of the world. It analyses the impacts across sectors and occupations, with a particular focus on manufacturing.
The report highlights that the impact of such a transition is positive for the EU as a whole, although with considerable variation between sectors. The positive impact on employment is largely due to the investment required to achieve this transition, along with the impact of lower spending on imported fossil fuels. The consequent shift in production has implications for labour market demand.
The analysis provides information on sectoral impacts, together with the Warwick Labour Market Extension model for occupational analysis. Further analysis of the employment developments in Europe is undertaken using Eurofound’s European Jobs Monitor.
